Home » Ronaldo Debate Reignites: Is Cristiano Still Untouchable in Portugal’s Starting XI?
Football

Ronaldo Debate Reignites: Is Cristiano Still Untouchable in Portugal’s Starting XI?

By Emmanuel Mbah

As Portugal prepare for what could be Cristiano Ronaldo’s final World Cup campaign, an old question has resurfaced with renewed intensity: Are the Selecao stronger without their legendary captain?, Puyaka.net reports

Ronaldo has already confirmed that this tournament will be his last appearance on football’s biggest stage. Yet despite concerns over his age and declining physical edge, there is little indication that Portugal will move away from the man who has defined their modern football history.

The discussion has divided fans, pundits and former internationals.

For former Portugal defender Abel Xavier, Ronaldo remains indispensable.

“Cristiano understands the big moments better than almost anyone in football,” Xavier said. “That experience can make the difference in a World Cup. Beyond the physical side, there is his technical ability and, most importantly, his mentality. Younger players look up to him and he always brings something extra to the team.”

Former Portugal goalkeeper Ricardo, who shared the pitch with Ronaldo during his international debut in 2003 and now works within the national team setup, shares that belief.

“The speed may not be exactly the same as before,” Ricardo noted. “But he is still operating at an incredibly high level. As long as the physical, technical and mental qualities remain, he is a dangerous player. When Cristiano is on the field, the threat is always there.”

Yet the numbers have fuelled a different narrative.

During Roberto Martinez’s tenure, Portugal recorded two of their most emphatic victories without Ronaldo. A stunning 9-0 demolition of Luxembourg in September 2023 and a 9-1 rout of Armenia last November immediately reignited claims that the team plays with greater freedom in his absence.

Football analyst Sofia Oliveira believes the debate cannot be ignored.

“He no longer has the football to be a starter for a team aiming to win the World Cup,” she argued. “The challenge is that Portugal have not spent the last few years preparing for a future without him.”

Martinez, however, has consistently brushed aside suggestions that Ronaldo’s place should be questioned.

The Portugal boss often points to one statistic that continues to strengthen his argument: 25 goals in Ronaldo’s last 31 appearances for the national team.

“We are talking about the greatest player of all time,” Martinez said. “He is here because he is still performing at a very high level, not because of what he achieved in the past.”

The figures certainly support the coach’s confidence. While Ronaldo may no longer dominate games with explosive pace, his finishing ability, movement and leadership continue to deliver results.

Now, as Portugal embark on another quest for World Cup glory, the spotlight once again falls on their iconic captain.

Having scored in each of his previous five World Cup appearances, Ronaldo stands on the brink of another record. His eight World Cup goals leave him just one shy of Portuguese legend Eusebio’s tally.

But individual milestones are unlikely to be his primary focus.

For a player who has conquered nearly every challenge the game has offered, one dream remains unfulfilled, leading Portugal to their first-ever World Cup triumph.

Whether Ronaldo is still the answer or part of a question Portugal must eventually confront could become one of the defining stories of the tournament.

About the author

Cosmos_Emeka

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment